

Directed By:
Joel Gallen
Roasters: Katt
Williams, Snoop Dog, Lisa Lampanelli, Ice T, Patton Oswalt, Jimmy
Kimmel, Carrot Top and many more.
What do you get
when you get a room full of insult comedians and an easy target?
A Roast.
The Show
The word roast
usually makes me think of something tasty, mouth watering, and
juicy. Roast in the comedic sense suggest someone is being burned
alive with humor. Insults usually make good comedy, as long as they
are tempered with some good flavorful ingredients and as long as
they don’t make up the entire comedic routine. If you go any further
than a few minutes, insults become tired and old. And, this show
becomes old really fast.
Conceptually,
the show sounds great. You get some comedians together ready to hurl
comments. You get quirky guests who can take jokes. And you put all
of this in front of an audience. Executed, the show does nothing.
It’s like taking the loads these comedians dropped into their
toilets and trying to smear it on a canvass and pass it as art.
(There have been art pieces made of dung that worked much better).
Rather telling is that the comedians have to read a lot of
their material, which is understandable given that the routine is
probably produced rather quickly. Yet, that leaves the comedy
unshaped and untested by the fire of audience trial.
Despite being
comedy from the ass end, the show keeps audience attention, much in
part to the number of comedians who change up the scene. Too, the
roasters take aim at fellow roasters and some audience members. And,
everyone takes it in stride. I kept waiting expectantly through each
comedian waiting for something that went beyond mildly amusing to
bust-a-gut funny. Although talented people sat upon the stage, there
was nothing laugh out loud funny in this
Roast. Sure, there were
some witty insults, but usually those aren’t so funny to me unless
I’m the one who is involved in them.
Don’t get me
wrong, I like insult comedy. I use it with my friends. But, for
performance comedy to be good to me it needs to be rounded with
various flavors of comedy: slap stick, whit, bawd, insult, irony,
etc. Instead of this Roast, you’d be better off going to McDonalds
and getting a Big Mac and fries.
3/10
The Video
Presented in
full screen format, the video quality is of normal TV caliber. It is
simply ok.
6/10
The Audio
In Dolby
Digital, the sound quality is steady and good for a TV production.
6/10
The Packaging
and Bonus Features
This
There are
several bonus features of happenings that take place before and
after the show. The lineup includes Red Carpet Interviews, a
Backstage Pass Preshow, a Backstage pass post show, Flavor Flav
gives a tour, and the Flav Cam.
5/10
When I realized that this film was directed by the same man responsible for the Ultimate Avengers II animated film the whole thing started making sense because that movie was pretty terrible too.
The Review
The Movie 3/10
The Video 6/10
The Audio 6/10
The Packaging
and Bonus Features 5/10
Overall (Not an
Average) 3/10
-Chuck Knight
The Best of the Best: DVD's of 2008
In Books: Tales From
The Farm:
Questions or Comments for the CineGeeks? Contact Us at info @ cinegeek.com!